St3lf's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[unfinished stick guy 2]

hmm

i think you were unlucky to get such a low score, it was worth more than 1.94. you can animate stickmen okay, not great, but okay. your basic movements arn't too bad. alot of your punches and kicks looked a bit choppy and there was far too much talking, it got a bit boring at times. im sure if you keep practising you'll get better :).

threassance responds:

o.k. thanks i'll surelly remeber to practice alot.

[SHOCK2]

awesome :)

i don't get it...it gets into the top 50, and daily 2nd and weekly 3rd...yet doesn't get front page? why? thats silly, it definately deserves it :(

but yeah...i think there may have been too much talking...and i prefer the first one to be perfectly honest, but im rating both episodes as one, and it was awesome :)

[Stick WAR Trailer]

looking good

hey this is fitzy off SP. it looks like the game will be good. just a suggestion though. i think it needs to be so that all units have strengths and weaknesses, obviously the lower units will have more weaknesses than strengths and the best ones will be strong...but every unit needs to have some sort of weakness, i hate games were you get to a point where you can just buy loads of one unit and wipe out the enemy, its much better when actual tactics and strategy are involved.

also, i know youve probably thought about this but im just saying that in prices for units...just make sure that if (for example), infantry is 1000 and a tank is 20000, 1 tank needs to be able to beat 20 infantry (although im sure you already had that sorted...but i have seen games where the pricing is terrible)...

but yeah it looks awesome, im not going to give the trailer 10/10 but it sure does make me look forward to the game, i love RTS games :) i hope it turns out well.

[Krom (Cr)]

that was good

first of all, you cant just submit it to a huge site and say 'dont vote on it, don't watch it'...this is what the site is MADE for...if you just want to upload your movie without people watching it, there are plenty of sites for that...

so, because you said that, i expected it to be crap, but it wasnt, it was some good stuff. a bit short but still very good...although i didn't know the language so im sure it wouldve been better if i did.

but yeah, it was better than i expected and actually was really good

[Black Vs White 3]

<3

Hey JC, fitzy here.

Firstly, frikkin well done on daily feature! thats awesome, good job...i was suprised yesterday when i came on the computer and saw 'black vs white 3' on the front page...congratulations :D, i knew you'd get an award eventually, i just never thought that your first one would be daily 1st :p.

and the movie was great too...as always, great effects and fights as always...a bit more confusing and less straight forward than the first 2 though :p. I think the next movie you need to make is a 'black vs red'...since thats what it looked like it was leading on to at the end. i watched it loads of times, it really is great. it took me quite a bit of time for it to make sense to me but it finally does :D.

if i had to make a critisism, it would be that it ended a bit suddenly, but besides that, there isn't much more to critisize. Just well done, i'm proud of you :D. Great job!

[Xiao Xiao No. 3]

great

always loved this series, it has inspired me alot. it's simple in style, but thats one of the things i love about it.

[The Blacksmith (Original)]

Woah, underratedness

wow, i cant believe how low the score is :-/. It deserves way higher, i think the soundtrack you originally used was better because i personally think it went more with the flow of the fight. but nonetheless, this deserves a much higher score. Possibly the lowness is the fact that its unfinished, but what was there was great and i dont understand how people can't appreciate the greatness of it. its a brilliant piece of work, exellent job. i think some of the hand to hand fighting could have been better (not saying it was bad or anything by any means). but the pole work and the scythe work was top notch. great job and exellent piece of work, but the score of not even 3.5 annoys me. i dont have anything more to say so i'll leave it there. this is fitzy off sp btw!

[My first stick fight]

much better than i expected

being honest, i expected a peice of crap. but because im fair i put it on just to make sure. and i was surprised, it was a good fight, not the best, but certainly not a piece of crap. the sticks shrank a bit and the fighting could have been dont better and the moves could have looked more forceful. but it was pretty good. i'll give a 5/10, but i voted 3 on the other thing. so yeah, not bad, keep it up (or not since you arnt doing another one)

Zombie-clock-monkey responds:

thx dude, good review

[Elimination 3 Preview]

cool

looking real cool, looking forward to it. but you spelled 'ultimate' wrong (you spelled it ultamite). but besides that, good work, cant wait for the real thing but since its only a preview i think you'll understand the lower marks.

Splurgle responds:

It's a preview, no need to carea bout the score. Thanks.

[How To Win Portal Awards]

hmmmm

I really dont call that an animation...why? because its not. its not hard to make something like this and i dont know why it passed. all you did was write what the award was, explained what you need to get it, and then how to get it...just in text. i seriously dont know how this passed.

Frenzy responds:

Lol, what a stupid review.

First sentence:

Yes this is an animation. There was no animation was there? Did you even WATCH THE FLASH?

Second sentence:

Yes it is, see explanation for sentence one for more information.

Third sentence:

It passed because NG users voted on it. The majority liked it, so it passed. This is all in the 'Literature' section under 'General FAQ/Portal Info' (or something like that).

Fourth Sentence:

Read the title of the movie.

Fifth sentence:

See my explanation for 'Sentence Three' for more information.

Wow... that was a very, very unintelligent review. There is something called capitalization. Stay in school! Oh, and for a 15 year old, you're not very intelligent. I'm 13, for gosh's sake.

Also,a 0 for sound? There was no sound? Also, I included voices, too, not just text.

Once again, this was a pretty dumb review.

Thanks for the review!
.frenZy.